• Seems some folks are disputing whether “American Pie” is overrated or merely overplayed. What’s your take?

    AC

  • rob

    Seems to me that overyplayed helps make it overrated. I mean, if a song isn’t played a lot, then how does it become overrated?

    Honestly, I don’t have a problem with most of the songs. I like them and don’t really consider them ‘overrated’. Though I never liked Freebird and Stairway to Heaven that much. They are overrated! 😉

    ‘Hey Ya’ hasn’t been around long enough to be on the list, IMO.